I think Rerez already proved that it’s not 100% perfect in their recent video as they break down how one game in particular has a timing based title screen that doesn’t align perfectly with the original hardware.
Also worth considering, old authentic hardware itself may have slowed down or sped up minutely similar to how SNES consoles have over the years.
But it’s so close that it’s basically imperceptible without a side by side as this person has even admitted. So they’re basically making a big stink over nothing.
The only people this is going to affect are speedrunners who won’t be able to use the analogue 3d in place of original hardware to submit runs.
I haven’t bought anything from them in a number of years, but I still love the work that they do. This is a real shame.
From a consumer aspect, I think their biggest problem is that most customers only have room in their homes for one, maybe two arcade machines (not counting collectors). That kind of fits them in the large appliance space which means they need a constant influx of new customers, or planned obsolescence. Unfortunately, the home arcade space is a niche market so it’s unlikely they’d see a continuous flux of new customers, especially when the prime demographic is older millennials and above.
I think what would have helped them would be to sell various styled cabinets and the actual arcade game with control deck separately. Something of a hybrid between arcade cabinet and home console. Want to play a different game? You don’t need a whole new cabinet taking up more of your limited living space. Just undock the control deck and dock in the new one. Blam, new arcade. If you don’t like your cabinet design, you can always buy a different one and your existing control decks would still work (in theory).
They could even go the extra mile and give their detachable control decks an HDMI out so you can plug them in to a television like those ∞-in-1 consoles.
This seems like it’s too good to be true. It really feels like an overpromised Kickstarter pitch that will ultimately fail to deliver on those promises and screws around with backers for years before ultimately, begrudgingly putting out a slapped together shoddy product that falls short of a good experience.
But only time will tell for sure. I know the Ryzen AI Max APU/NPUs (whichever they are categorized as) are supposed to be almost magical, but I’d still be wary of backing this one myself.
Fake trailers have been a thing since video streaming on the internet. Although, IP protection has been increasing in recent years as well. I could see this case going either way.
I wonder if the quality and success of the Analogue 3D had anything to do with this. Harder to put out an inferior (for the sake of argument, there’s no basis for this claim) product when there’s a good example for everyone to point to.
He’s not wrong. It’s already happening.
AI generated websites taking advantage of SEO to generate clicks and ad revenue just filling in whatever information it wants to, then AI search summaries like Gemini take these things at face value and repeat it confidently incorrectly. Users don’t verify the information because when you’re searching for a quick answer, you’re not looking to put in the same effort as writing a thesis.
How many ‘users’ out there on social media sites are just bots or AI talking to each other? I’m not suggesting we’re in the dead Internet theory, but we are watching it happen right now.
The Internet is one of the great wonders of the world. It brought the age of global information to the world. Who would have thought flooding every corner of it with the firehose of falsehoods would be a good idea?
I would 100% buy this if N64 cartridges were still in production. As it stands, I no longer have any of my old N64 games, so my interest in this product is merely one of nostalgic excitement. I’m glad this exists and is as good as it is.
The mechanic of hitting rupees and hearts with your weapon to pick them up is from the original CD-i games. While I commend the port maker’s commitment to the demake, this mechanic was unnecessary to carry over.
I’ll be interested if they’re going to do anything unique with the software side of things, or if it’s going to be just yet another ‘GAMER!’ Android skin. Hardware hasn’t excited me on smartphones for several years now.
@Damo Procedural generation has its limitations. Working alongside generative AI could, theoretically, make it better. That’s what I was trying to get at with my comment.
I don’t support this use of AI, but I also think people are extremely negatively reactive to AI as a whole, even in cases where it’s actually useful and makes sense. The horror game genre is one place where it could be a good use case for generative AI. One of the biggest issues with horror games is once you’ve identified the mechanics behind everything, the game becomes much less scary. This is something that AI can solve through randomly generated events and unique spooks; things that you can’t just point to the underlying game logic to demystify it. It seems specially suited for games that rely on randomized and tile-based events, like the Diablo series for example. But I definitely don’t support it taking the place of skilled human labor, and especially not art.
I mean if you’re completely redesigning the game from the ground up and even changing the story, then I guess you don’t really need the original design documents or reference materials. It’d be different if they were doing a remaster, but the remake trilogy isn’t a remaster.
The design and placement of the buttons below the screen remind me a lot of the original 3DS. I didn’t care much for that design, and I think the design here feels antiquated, but not necessarily bad.
I misread “brought that rivalry to an end” in the trailer for “bought that rivalry to an end” which is actually more fitting.
One point of note, and this is from someone who has no nostalgia glasses for the Intellivision, is that the controller overlays are going to be a huge nuisance. Perhaps it would be better to have a cheap e-ink screen behind the inputs that could change to the appropriate game overlay. Something like that would probably raise the costs and thus price of the console quite a bit though, making it potentially infeasible.
Lastly, this is an unholy union. It would be like if Nintendo released a new Genesis console.
@WhiteUmbrella Thanks for that info. Just wanted to add that I finally received my email for this today. IIRC I think I jumped aboard a bit late, so the delay in receiving the email likely correlates to the order ‘line’.
This tickles the hardware enthusiast in me, but I’ve never been attached to the Atari brand or games. The emulation bonus is pretty cool, but probably not enough to justify it l when there are a multitude of better portable emulation devices. It does LOOK really cool though. I suppose at a glance, without having the hardware in my hands, the most annoying element to this is how they have the Atari branding in the UI right below the Atari branding on the hardware.
@WhiteUmbrella Same here. I put the $5 down on the Superdock preorder and never received a follow-up email after my order confirmation. I’m assuming they’ll send purchase links out once it’s closer to shipping.
My favorite part of this article is how your described all of the terrible things the executives were doing and I’m just here thinking the entire time “huh, so they’re basically acting like every single company in 2025.”
I’d like to believe this will all end up with a lot of people in legal trouble for botched raid at best, actual cronyism at worst, but realistically I know they’ll all get away with it because corporation.
Well SEGA, congratulations. I was going to pick up the new Sonic racing game, but now I’m having second thoughts.
I feel like Atari is putting the cart before the horse here. They’re revealing and launching way too many hardware products when anything and everything under the sun (including a plethora of their own licensed products) can and does play basically the entire Atari library of games already.
What Atari needs to focus on right now is polishing their brand after it’s been passed around like a… well, best not to say. That comes in the way of putting their heads down and really focusing on delivering solid, polished SOFTWARE experiences to build up a fan base first. These aren’t the 80s when there’s little competition in the console space anymore. You need to do more than make a shiny video about some new retro handheld.
I mean do we really need 3 new ways to play Pac-Man?
It really feels like they’re trying to flood the market with Atari products, and we all know what happened the last time Atari flooded the market.
Comments 43
Re: This Switch-Sized Handheld Packed With Capcom And Bandai Namco Games Is Finally Launching This Year
This looks like it was designed by AI.
Re: We're Now Entering The Era Of Folding-Screen Gaming Handhelds
I’m interested in how this performs. Having a folding screen would be cool for both dual screen emulation as well as seamless 4:3 content.
Re: Prices Of Second-Hand Nintendo 3DS Consoles Spike Online
I still love my New 3DS XL. I just kinda wish I could get better screens in there and maybe a little upscaling. Also more official replacement parts.
Re: Pre-Orders For The SN Operator, Your Next Essential SNES Accessory, Open Today
@RetroGames I agree. I think demand would be low, however. Still… it would be nice to have some officially licensed repros.
Re: "Long Lost" Genesis Sequel To Pit Fighter Is Found, Thanks To The VGHF
Someone should go let Matt McMuscles know about this.
Re: "They Lied" - New Research Casts Doubt On Analogue 3D Accuracy Claims
I think Rerez already proved that it’s not 100% perfect in their recent video as they break down how one game in particular has a timing based title screen that doesn’t align perfectly with the original hardware.
Also worth considering, old authentic hardware itself may have slowed down or sped up minutely similar to how SNES consoles have over the years.
But it’s so close that it’s basically imperceptible without a side by side as this person has even admitted. So they’re basically making a big stink over nothing.
The only people this is going to affect are speedrunners who won’t be able to use the analogue 3d in place of original hardware to submit runs.
Re: The Video Game History Foundation Has Just Recovered A Treasure Trove Of Previously Undumped Sega Channel Games
Ooh this is an exciting part of lost media and my childhood.
Re: Reports Suggest Arcade1Up Is Shutting Down
I haven’t bought anything from them in a number of years, but I still love the work that they do. This is a real shame.
From a consumer aspect, I think their biggest problem is that most customers only have room in their homes for one, maybe two arcade machines (not counting collectors). That kind of fits them in the large appliance space which means they need a constant influx of new customers, or planned obsolescence. Unfortunately, the home arcade space is a niche market so it’s unlikely they’d see a continuous flux of new customers, especially when the prime demographic is older millennials and above.
I think what would have helped them would be to sell various styled cabinets and the actual arcade game with control deck separately. Something of a hybrid between arcade cabinet and home console. Want to play a different game? You don’t need a whole new cabinet taking up more of your limited living space. Just undock the control deck and dock in the new one. Blam, new arcade. If you don’t like your cabinet design, you can always buy a different one and your existing control decks would still work (in theory).
They could even go the extra mile and give their detachable control decks an HDMI out so you can plug them in to a television like those ∞-in-1 consoles.
Re: The "2-In-1" OneXPlayer Super X Looks Like An Emulation Powerhouse
This seems like it’s too good to be true. It really feels like an overpromised Kickstarter pitch that will ultimately fail to deliver on those promises and screws around with backers for years before ultimately, begrudgingly putting out a slapped together shoddy product that falls short of a good experience.
But only time will tell for sure. I know the Ryzen AI Max APU/NPUs (whichever they are categorized as) are supposed to be almost magical, but I’d still be wary of backing this one myself.
Re: Abxylute's $70 Retro Gaming Handheld Runs Android And Linux
It looks like a Toughbook in style.
Re: Analogue 3D Is Getting Some "Funtastic" Case Options
Yes! Yes! Bring back the Play it Loud marketing. I love to see it.
Re: Sorry Shenmue Fans, But That "Leaked" 'Shenmue 4' Trailer Isn't Real After All
@MARl0 I think I agree with you.
Re: Sorry Shenmue Fans, But That "Leaked" 'Shenmue 4' Trailer Isn't Real After All
Fake trailers have been a thing since video streaming on the internet. Although, IP protection has been increasing in recent years as well. I could see this case going either way.
Re: "We Believe This Is The Right Step" - Unofficial FPGA Sega Neptune Gets Pushed Into 2026
I wonder if the quality and success of the Analogue 3D had anything to do with this. Harder to put out an inferior (for the sake of argument, there’s no basis for this claim) product when there’s a good example for everyone to point to.
Re: This One-Of-A-Kind Sonic Arcade Machine Could Fetch Over $50,000 At Auction
Hope they’re watching out for SEGA-sponsored police raids.
Re: This Banjo-Kazooie Fan Game Took 14 Months & 800+ Hours Of Work, But You'll Need A PS4 Or A PS5 To Play It
This looks gorgeous and well made.
Re: "AI Is Gonna Eventually Eat Itself... Like When We Fed Cows With Cows And Got Mad Cow Disease"
He’s not wrong. It’s already happening.
AI generated websites taking advantage of SEO to generate clicks and ad revenue just filling in whatever information it wants to, then AI search summaries like Gemini take these things at face value and repeat it confidently incorrectly. Users don’t verify the information because when you’re searching for a quick answer, you’re not looking to put in the same effort as writing a thesis.
How many ‘users’ out there on social media sites are just bots or AI talking to each other? I’m not suggesting we’re in the dead Internet theory, but we are watching it happen right now.
The Internet is one of the great wonders of the world. It brought the age of global information to the world. Who would have thought flooding every corner of it with the firehose of falsehoods would be a good idea?
Re: Did Somebody Say 'Nintendo 64 Pro'? Watch The Analogue 3D's Overclocked Mode In Action
I would 100% buy this if N64 cartridges were still in production. As it stands, I no longer have any of my old N64 games, so my interest in this product is merely one of nostalgic excitement. I’m glad this exists and is as good as it is.
Re: Duke Nukem 3D Is About To Get An Ambitious New Mod That Replaces Its 2D Sprites With "Nearly A Thousand Voxels"
It’s really hard to tell what has been changed. Perhaps a slower showcase would have been better than a quick-transition action-packed trailer.
Re: Dreamcast Community Unite! Dream Disc '25 Is Just Around The Corner
I love this. The Dreamcast was highly underrated and I love to see it continue to receive support this far into the future.
Re: "Forgotten" Zelda Adventure Gets Ported To Game Boy Color With Special 'DX' Update
The mechanic of hitting rupees and hearts with your weapon to pick them up is from the original CD-i games. While I commend the port maker’s commitment to the demake, this mechanic was unnecessary to carry over.
Re: GameTank Is "An Entirely New Breed Of Hardware For The Next Generation Of 8-bit Games"
I admire the dream, but let’s see if reality is as kind.
Re: Sorry Nintendo, But It Doesn't Look Like Switch Will Overtake PS2 As The Best-Selling Console Of All Time
It’s a little hard to win when your biggest competitor keeps magicking new sales numbers out of nowhere every time you get close.
Re: Retroid Confirms Rapper Soulja Boy "Does Not Have Permission" To Rebrand And Sell Its Handhelds
@The_Nintendo_Pedant Never let a little failure get in the way of a good grift or you’ll never become president.
Re: "A Mobile Phone Truly Made For Gamers" - AYANEO's Next Trick Is Making A Smartphone
I’ll be interested if they’re going to do anything unique with the software side of things, or if it’s going to be just yet another ‘GAMER!’ Android skin.
Hardware hasn’t excited me on smartphones for several years now.
Re: The Oliver Twins Are Reviving Ghost Hunters Using (Shudder) Generative AI
@Damo Procedural generation has its limitations. Working alongside generative AI could, theoretically, make it better. That’s what I was trying to get at with my comment.
Re: The Oliver Twins Are Reviving Ghost Hunters Using (Shudder) Generative AI
I don’t support this use of AI, but I also think people are extremely negatively reactive to AI as a whole, even in cases where it’s actually useful and makes sense.
The horror game genre is one place where it could be a good use case for generative AI. One of the biggest issues with horror games is once you’ve identified the mechanics behind everything, the game becomes much less scary. This is something that AI can solve through randomly generated events and unique spooks; things that you can’t just point to the underlying game logic to demystify it. It seems specially suited for games that rely on randomized and tile-based events, like the Diablo series for example.
But I definitely don’t support it taking the place of skilled human labor, and especially not art.
Re: "There's Basically Nothing" - Final Fantasy VII Remake's Director Reveals "Almost No Documentation" Exists For The Original
I mean if you’re completely redesigning the game from the ground up and even changing the story, then I guess you don’t really need the original design documents or reference materials. It’d be different if they were doing a remaster, but the remake trilogy isn’t a remaster.
Re: "We Heard You" - Retroid Pocket 6 Landing Page Pulled Following Complaints About Its "Ugly" Design
The design and placement of the buttons below the screen remind me a lot of the original 3DS. I didn’t care much for that design, and I think the design here feels antiquated, but not necessarily bad.
Re: "You Wouldn't See Street Fighter Or Tekken Putting This Garbage Out" - Mortal Kombat Art Book Accused Of Using AI Upscaling
Honestly, if there wasn’t a disclaimer that AI was used, every single person should be entitled to a refund.
Re: "We Brought The Rivalry To An End" - Atari Reveals The Intellivision Sprint
@Zeebor15 Then I am dumb and misread. My bad.
Re: "We Brought The Rivalry To An End" - Atari Reveals The Intellivision Sprint
@Zeebor15 “Nintendo didn’t make a Genesis controller.”
Check again?
https://www.nintendo.com/us/store/products/sega-genesis-control-pad-114295/
(Pedantic, I know.)
Re: "We Brought The Rivalry To An End" - Atari Reveals The Intellivision Sprint
I misread “brought that rivalry to an end” in the trailer for “bought that rivalry to an end” which is actually more fitting.
One point of note, and this is from someone who has no nostalgia glasses for the Intellivision, is that the controller overlays are going to be a huge nuisance. Perhaps it would be better to have a cheap e-ink screen behind the inputs that could change to the appropriate game overlay. Something like that would probably raise the costs and thus price of the console quite a bit though, making it potentially infeasible.
Lastly, this is an unholy union. It would be like if Nintendo released a new Genesis console.
Re: EGGCONSOLE Publisher Pulls Reissue Of PC-88 RPG 'Burai: Joukan' After Complaints From The Game's Creator
“This isn't the first time that EGGCONSOLE has run into trouble for the unauthorized use of someone else's software without permission.”
One more and they can redeem their punchcard for a free coffee (which may or may not be stolen).
Re: "We Spent The Last Eight Months Creating A User-Friendly Frontend" - Taki Udon Shows Off SuperStation One's 'Console Mode' UI
@WhiteUmbrella
Thanks for that info. Just wanted to add that I finally received my email for this today. IIRC I think I jumped aboard a bit late, so the delay in receiving the email likely correlates to the order ‘line’.
Re: Review: Atari Gamestation Go - A Tour Of Atari's Legacy With One Too Many Bumps In The Road
This tickles the hardware enthusiast in me, but I’ve never been attached to the Atari brand or games. The emulation bonus is pretty cool, but probably not enough to justify it l when there are a multitude of better portable emulation devices.
It does LOOK really cool though.
I suppose at a glance, without having the hardware in my hands, the most annoying element to this is how they have the Atari branding in the UI right below the Atari branding on the hardware.
Re: "We Spent The Last Eight Months Creating A User-Friendly Frontend" - Taki Udon Shows Off SuperStation One's 'Console Mode' UI
@WhiteUmbrella Same here. I put the $5 down on the Superdock preorder and never received a follow-up email after my order confirmation. I’m assuming they’ll send purchase links out once it’s closer to shipping.
Re: "It Shouldn't Be That Way" - Tetris Company CEO Laments Low Female Representation In The Games Industry
If they want to.
Re: Italian Museum Uncovers Blueprints To Historic Lost Sega Game From The 1970s
Watch out, Italian Museum… SEGA is probably already working with local authorities to illegally raid and steal your property.
Re: 40 Years After It Launched, This Fan-Made Remake Has Given Us The Ultimate Way To Play Super Mario Bros.
Now that the litigious comment seal has been broken…
I can’t wait to play this ga-aaand it’s gone.
(Jk, but maybe true by the time you’re reading this)
Re: "The Worst Console Of All Time" Turned 20 This Year – Is Gizmondo Worth A Look In 2025?
My favorite part of this article is how your described all of the terrible things the executives were doing and I’m just here thinking the entire time “huh, so they’re basically acting like every single company in 2025.”
Re: Sega Accused Of Using Police To Recover Nintendo Dev Kits It Had "Negligently Disposed Of"
I’d like to believe this will all end up with a lot of people in legal trouble for botched raid at best, actual cronyism at worst, but realistically I know they’ll all get away with it because corporation.
Well SEGA, congratulations. I was going to pick up the new Sonic racing game, but now I’m having second thoughts.
Re: The Atari Gamestation Go Launches Next Month
I feel like Atari is putting the cart before the horse here. They’re revealing and launching way too many hardware products when anything and everything under the sun (including a plethora of their own licensed products) can and does play basically the entire Atari library of games already.
What Atari needs to focus on right now is polishing their brand after it’s been passed around like a… well, best not to say. That comes in the way of putting their heads down and really focusing on delivering solid, polished SOFTWARE experiences to build up a fan base first. These aren’t the 80s when there’s little competition in the console space anymore. You need to do more than make a shiny video about some new retro handheld.
I mean do we really need 3 new ways to play Pac-Man?
It really feels like they’re trying to flood the market with Atari products, and we all know what happened the last time Atari flooded the market.