Comments 132

Re: "Extremely Disappointing" - Are AI-Generated FPGA Cores The Future, Or The Death Of Accuracy?

RextheSheep

"Playable first, accuracy whatever" doesn't even make sense for the MiSTer project. There are definitely cores that aren't 100% accurate, sure, but rushing to make games playable with no intent of maintaining the cores long term just feels wrong.

My stance will always be the same whether it's this or whether it's vibe coded N64-to-PC ports. What matters is how good the result is, not that you got a result at all. People are growing impatient with basic projects that do bugger all to actually improve on existing solutions.

Re: "A Hollow Victory" - '100% AI-Generated' Smash Bros. PC Port Comes Under Fire

RextheSheep

@chucksneed The initial release of the port isn't even playable to completion because it crashes or hangs in regular gameplay.

Supposing for a moment that you're not being disingenuous with your comment. Everyone I've spoken to in the N64 port community have been as accommodating as they can be regardless of their opinions on AI-generated coding, but ultimately what matters is the result, and the result doesn't even meet the most basic standards of functionality.

Also, despite the good intentions behind it, there's little confidence that this project will receive long-term support. I've spoken to the developer personally and, while he intends to try and address the issues, by his own admission, he isn't able to answer basic questions about how the port functions, because he isn't an experienced coder and hasn't spent much time in the code himself. Even if this port had zero issues, what's the point in using all these resources (and about $500 in subscriptions and tokens) to create a black box that nobody even understands? It's honestly just a waste of everyone's time.

Re: MAME Set To Introduce Changes To Its System Requirements & "The Frequency Of Releases"

RextheSheep

@ruiner9 Honestly given how many people run MAME cabinets with old PCs that aren't connected to the internet, it'll surely inconvenience someone. Although on the other hand, I doubt those people are keeping MAME up to date anyway.

The old versions remain for anyone keeping MAME running on retro setups regardless. – Although to be honest, it may be a better idea in the long run to install Linux on that bad boy.

Re: Looks Like Zool Is The Latest '90s Mascot To Get A Revival

RextheSheep

I've always had a soft spot for Zool. I particularly like the Sega Master System and Game Gear versions.

Urbanscan btw is Ian Stewart's company and the rights holder of a lot of the Gremlin Graphics back catalogue. It's been around for a while and they've put the name on all sorts of things, some new games, mostly re-releases.

Re: Native PC Ports Of PS2 Games Could Be On The Way Thanks To New Recompilation "Experiment"

RextheSheep

@X68000 Well, you can decompile anything. So long as machine code was built from a compiled language, it can be decompiled. We've had reverse engineering tools to facilitate this for decades.

What these static recompilation tools do is provide a framework to facilitate the porting from one architecture to another without the immediate need for the original source code or a full decompilation. That it can be partially automated to this degree is why it's so exciting to people.