Damo

Damo

The boy who never grew up.

Comments 950

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@DestructoDisk I appreciate you sharing your thoughts. Unfortunately, journalism isn't just about covering the stuff that makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside, and AI and its abuse of copyright is becoming a hot topic in all industries, especially creative ones like the video game sector. We're far from the only site covering these topics, and I personally feel we'd be doing our audience a disservice if we just acted like these things don't matter in the wider context.

I think we still cover enough fun stuff for you to stick around, but that's just my opinion.

Time Extension is never, ever going to be one of those sites which just says "don't question, just consume", I'm afraid.

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@somnambulance There's no misunderstanding, and, like so many AI users, you're skirting around the issue here - the AI models you use are trained on copyrighted human music without permission.

Even the ones which claim to ethically trained have been exposed as using content without permission or remuneration.

https://practicalaudiolab.substack.com/p/the-ethical-facade-crumbles-inside

Now, you might not care about this, and that's fine, but surely you can see why so many musicians are less than pleased that they have been unwillingly used to train their replacement?

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@slider1983 "Servers contribute to damage in the environment. If we're going to stand on our soap boxes to complain about AI you would also need to complain about websites including this one that uses servers."

Data centre construction has massively accelerated since the AI boom took hold. That's a fact. And AI-focused data centres consume more water and generate more heat. We've had the internet for decades and it's only since AI took off that their rapid expansion, energy demands and environmental impact have become an issue.

Give this a read: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckg2ldpl9leo

"That is a good point. It's pretty much the same thing. It's a correlation of different sources"

I don't even know where to begin on this one. I'm not sure you even understand what you're saying, or if you know enough about how generative AI works.

More reading for you: https://theconversation.com/we-need-to-stop-pretending-ai-is-intelligent-heres-how-254090

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@kiba999 No other method of mass production uses human-made content as its raw material. And if AI companies were forced to pay for the data they use for training, then the entire industry would go under. Many of these companies aren't making a profit yet despite not paying a single penny for the data they have taken without permission.

And AI doesn't empower people. It removes power, as detailed here: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20260417-ai-chatbots-could-be-making-you-stupider

"rather than attempt to maintain a form of individualism that doesn't exist and never existed"

I can tell you have zero appreciation for human-made art. That's a real shame.

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@LorentzFactor

AI does not "learn" like a human, and this has been proven multiple times by in-depth studies:

https://the-decoder.com/researchers-extract-up-to-96-of-harry-potter-word-for-word-from-leading-ai-models/

https://copyrightalliance.org/ai-training-is-not-human-learning/

You've also danced around the part where AI is created by billion dollar companies to pump out derivative work at an enormous scale for profit.

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@willstancilfan So you've really taken the "Yet you participate in society" route here? Hilarious.

No, I don't agree with the current push by tech firms to use AI for everything (Cloudflare just sacked a bunch of its staff for this very reason), and it's even more disappointing when you consider Cloudflare's boss was pushing for a way of renumerating creators when AI scrapes their data.

(Yes, we use Cloudflare for some images, but we're actually hosted by https://www.44bytes.net/)

The reality is every single tech firm on the planet is using AI in some way, shape or form - I don't have to be OK with that, just as I'm sure many people don't agree 100% with what their respective government is doing at the moment. That's why it's vital to make sure you voice your opinion whenever possible.

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@TV4Fun AI models have been tested and can reproduce, word for word, entire books. No human is capable of doing that. That's not the same as being 'inspired' like a human writer or artist is; AI cannot do anything without the data it has consumed. It lacks imagination; it is merely mashing together thousands of human-made images to produce a copy, which is why a lot of AI art is instantly recognisable.

"Why is this only an argument against AI and not any of the thousands of other things we have used computers for over the last 70+ years?"

Those things are bad, too - the issue here is that AI has massively accelerated the construction of huge data centres, and increased the consumption of water – not to mention the sound pollution which has been reported in communities living near these buildings.

Like so many pro-AI people, you seem to completely ignore the theft angle in your replies. Do you think it's right that massive companies like Meta, Google and Microsoft have scraped data without permission so they can sell it back to people as 'tools' which produce low-quality slop? And line their pockets in the process?

Just as my line of debate hasn't convinced you, your argument has failed dismally to change my mind.

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@Dustybin1 The whole 'automation' argument (a favoured point by pro-AI people) misses the point that without the endless amount of stolen training data available online, AI would be useless.

The car made the horse redundant, but it didn't steal anything from the horse - that was an evolution.

AI is merely theft on a grand scale, lining the pockets of massive tech companies that have cunningly avoided paying for the data used to train these (often laughably incorrect) models. The end goal seems to be to replace the most costly aspect of business - people - with AI. There's no 'enrichment' or 'enpowerment' of society here; people cost money, take sick days, go on holiday, have benefits and rights... these are all things that most CEOs would happily do without if they could (and they already are).

Perhaps you need to read up a bit on some of these issues, then you might actually care.

Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release

Damo

@Dustybin1 GenAI is trained on human-made art without permission or remuneration, and competes directly with human artists, thousands of whom are now losing out on work thanks to people using AI. The issues here are pretty obvious. Perhaps if you were one of the human artists who had unwillingly trained their replacement, you might be more sensitive to the issue?

This is before we even touch upon the environmental issues related to AI, and the drive to build massive, harmful data centres near people's homes.

Re: Talking Point: "We, The Consumers, Need To Vote With Our Wallets" - The Moral Dilemma Of Supporting SNK In 2026

Damo

Re: Talking Point: "We, The Consumers, Need To Vote With Our Wallets" - The Moral Dilemma Of Supporting SNK In 2026

Damo

@X68000 Never mentioned at all? You might want to have a little look back through our historical coverage of SNK (both on this site and the wider network). The Saudi ownership is mentioned multiple times.

And you seem to think we've taken a hard stance on this issue - we're still going to be covering SNK. We're just taking the time to make sure people are aware of what's happening behind the scenes at the company.

Re: Talking Point: "We, The Consumers, Need To Vote With Our Wallets" - The Moral Dilemma Of Supporting SNK In 2026

Damo

@X68000 I say in the piece that we could well be accused of being hypocritical. We're not above scrutiny here; the ModRetro situation hopefully proves that. Perhaps the way we tackle SNK in the future will evolve... or perhaps the MiSK foundation will divest the company in time and fix the issue for us, as it appears to be backing out of a lot of its financial commitments at the moment.

Re: "I Know Some People Don't Like This" - Final Fight MD's Latest Project Uses GenAI

Damo

@Martin_H "They" is me, as I'm one of the co-owners.

And as we have staff all over the world, we allow them to pick and choose if they work on a UK Bank Holiday (the number of UK Bank Holidays is automatically added to the yearly holiday allowance, to be taken when each staff member sees fit).

Hope that explains why I'm working (I'm off for the rest of the week from tomorrow!)

Re: "I Know Some People Don't Like This" - Final Fight MD's Latest Project Uses GenAI

Damo

@SlangWon He earns money from his Patreon, and there are real musicians out there who would be willing to work with him despite the small amount of money involved.

Or he could even create the music himself, as developers did back in the day. Passing the task off to a computer trained without permission on human-made work doesn't seem like the right route to take, IMO.

Re: They Buried My Beloved CeX

Damo

@cawley1 I have a notepad full of those old CeX stickers. I'll find a photo and add it to the piece when I get a chance!

@RenderSpotlight Sadly that area of Birmingham has gone downhill over the past two decades. In the glory days there was was a run of shops down there, with Virgin and CeX being the crowning glory. I think Games Workshop was on that row of shops too, at one point.

@Spookles The smell was certainly something, but not unpleasant for some reason... nostalgia, perhaps?

@mashk I think I sold my first copy og Panzer Dragoon Saga to this branch when I traded up to my Dreamcast, also for a pittance