Comments 140

Re: "This Is From Zelda, If You Didn't Know" - Test Footage Highlights The Danger Of Using GenAI In Video Game Development

MontyMole

@h3s “ Well things change with the times”

People need to eat. That doesn’t change with the times.

““ But I care more about the original purpose of copyright (To encourage stuff to be created in the first place). ””

The US copyright law was ripped directly from British copyright law, which purpose was to prevent monopoly of book publishing, which in turn promoted more accessible education. In a way this promotes creation too, as the artist gets paid and can continue to work.

In my opinion, the problem with AI in general is not how it can help us do things efficiently and faster; but how it enables monopoly. Large corporations intend to use it for all fhe wrong reasons and after all, their goal is monopoly.

Allowing companies to use GenAi with abandon is simply enabling them to work without that annoying problem of paying people for their work.

Believe it or not, I’m not anti+AI at all. It’s an exciting technology in many ways and I use it almost daily, as most do I’m sure. We need boundaries though and they haven’t yet been established. If the companies piling their money into AI have their way, those boundaries will remain unchallenged and how can that not end badly?

Re: "This Is From Zelda, If You Didn't Know" - Test Footage Highlights The Danger Of Using GenAI In Video Game Development

MontyMole

@h3s “ using small bits of copywriter stuff has always been accepted (Like libraries were okay with 5% of a book being photocopied.) A lot of this is just updating long held principles for the modern age.”

I don’t get the comparison to be honest. Photocopying a book is fair usage for certain purposes, but replacing the authors name with your own definitely isn’t.

I’m reminded of when Biz Markie (or his publisher at least) got sued for using uncredited samples in the early 90s. The judge famously opened his verdict with “thou shalt not steal”.

Re: Random Game Saturday: Shining The Holy Ark (Sega Saturn)

MontyMole

I arrived late to the show with the Shining series, but absolutely loved Shining force 1 and 2 via the megadrive compilation. I just can’t get into “Darkness” though (and I’ve really tried), so Holy Ark is probably not going to be my thing.

It’s interesting that they made another Dungeon Crawler though, after the success of “Force”.

Re: "That Made Me Feel Good" - Xbox Co-Founder On The Rare Game "Strongly Echoed" By Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom

MontyMole

“ Rare is trying very original, new things all the time. And when you do that in the game business, most of them are going to fail.”

Not a statement I particularly agree with. I worked with game developers a few times and every single time I was astounded by all the talent and personal commitment that people put into a project, only to decide that marketing isn’t too important and is something they can do themselves.

The run that Nintendo had with Wii and NDS is proof enough that “very original things” will sell like hotcakes if marketed competently.

Re: The Neo Geo+ AES Saves You Over $92,000 On The Real Deal

MontyMole

II’m glad it was reported here, even if it does rub some people the wrong way. Our purchases very rightly should be a personal choice, without coercion from others. I will always be glad to be given an informed choice though.

Luckily for me, I can’t afford one, even at these prices, so I’m spared having to ride my own cognitive dissonance!

Re: "No Emulation, No Compromise, No Comparison" - The $250 Neo Geo+ AES Aims To Be A 1:1 Replica Of SNK's Classic Console

MontyMole

@Dr_Fresh “ and also I don't think Plaion Replai manufactures lethal drones, so that's a plus.”

True, but SNK are majority owned by EGDC, the same company who are slowly eating into Capcom (currently 6% owned). EGDC is owned by the “not for profit” MISK foundation and the person not profiting the most from that venture is none other than Mohammed bin Salman.

If anyone isn’t aware at this point of his track record, just give him a google; particularly for his coalition in Yemen, which murdered 1000s of innocent people by bombing schools and hospitals and a blockade that stopped medical supplies entering the country and resulted in famine. The list does go on…

Re: Double Dragon Creator Yoshihisa Kishimoto Has Passed Away

MontyMole

@MontyCircus “ I've read people say that Kung Fu Master is the first beat 'em up.
But when I saw Double Dragon for the first time, I didn't say "Cool, it's just like Kung Fu Master". It was its own thing. ”

I don’t think there’s a strong argument against Kung Fu Master being a beat em up game, but Kishimoto also made Renegade before Double Dragon.

Re: "I'm Just Enjoying Building Software With Those New Tools" - Yaba Sanshiro Dev Credits AI With Saturn Emulator's Renewed Momentum

MontyMole

@RootsGenoa “ For me, the biggest problem is the enormous use of energy.”

Plus one for me. Possibly my only issue with AI, aside from how most people use it.

The rest is history repeating itself. I have an illustrator friend who made a multi million fortune, (which he frittered away in the classic manner.) He said he didn’t embrace digital tools when they arrived and stated many of the reasons I hear people complain about AI now. The people who replaced him are now in the same position. Jobs and quality of product threatened by an emerging technology.

Re: Every Shining Game, Ranked

MontyMole

@Jellyscare “ The great thing about this article format is that it tells you which are worth playing and which aren’t.”

To an extent, but naturally, it's a subjective article. I can’t find anything to enjoy about Shining in the Darkness, but it’s fairly high on this list. If I played that first (and probably would have originally, if I had actually realised it was the first game), I might have missed out on the next 2, which are classics imho.

Re: "Time To Expose Everything" - Fallout From Sega Dev Kit Raid Rumbles On

MontyMole

@N64-ROX ironically enough, this entire saga has an air of tabloid press sensationalism. I haven’t really followed the story and possibly wouldn’t know about it at all, if not for the exposure here. He could have used that exposure to engage and inform and then more people might be on his side.

From the outset, the story has been drip fed and full of holes and feels more like a conspiracy or attention seeking to my spidey senses at least. I’m not saying it’s a fraud; I simply need more useful information to make an informed decision.

If he’s right, then he deserves the weight of all the gaming communities behind him, but currently (and again, I’m only going from what people say here) he just seems to be throwing insults and stomping his feet.

As for Nintendolife, the clue is in the name. You’re not going to get too much common sense there if it doesn’t fit the Nintendo PR template!

Re: "Time To Expose Everything" - Fallout From Sega Dev Kit Raid Rumbles On

MontyMole

@N64-ROX Had to delete my original reply, as I skimmed your comment and misunderstood. Tabloid basically means condensed news, but in the U.K. at least became synonymous with trashy type magazine style papers aimed at the (ahem) working classes. I guess this site features tabloid type news, but not at all in the sense that The Sun newspaper does!

Re: 3DS Emulation Just Keeps On Getting Better

MontyMole

@Razieluigi The 3D was genuinely great at times. The old school Sega and Nes games especially stand out (pun intended).

It’s a shame that developers got lazy with the 3D so quickly. Even Nintendo’s own efforts were basically autoconversion’s eventually.

These days I rarely use the 3D effect, simply because I’m scared of breaking the slider!

Re: "That Was The Big Crown Jewel" - Guitar Hero Dev Recalls Losing The Battle For The Beatles Rights To Harmonix

MontyMole

The guitar hero games (on Wii as that’s all I have enough experience to comment) just felt more like playing an instrument. I’m a musician and maybe you are and disagree? That’s fine.

I played this game with the guitar hero peripherals and at the time I was playing a digital drum kit in real life. The experience was so much more realistic in guitar hero as my memory serves. I recently bought a Wii and guitar controller, but have yet to find a well priced drum controller to test my memory…

Re: Best Of 2025: "Music Is Pretty Much All I Think About" - PaRappa The Rapper's Creator On His Journey From Pop Star To Game Dev

MontyMole

@GodlessPreservation I’ve been a sound engineer for close to 30 years and I hear stuff like this regularly. It’s not the notes you play, it’s the space between them that makes the track, etc. This is just a creative way of thinking and what sets them apart from the rest of us!

Reminded me of when Takemura said his final piece of music would be a single sound, 2 seconds long, or when Brian Wilson wrote Good Vibrations and called his friend into the room to listen and he just played the same note over and over again, haha.