"A true decompilation/recompilation of the game is in the works via yaz0r." Unfortunately he is quite depressed by all the AI-based decompilations and this one won't help...
I find always weird Time Extension's editors like to write 'later this month' when it's actually THIS WEEK. I mean, isn't it better to have to wait less?
"Now, as for scraping IP and all of that kind of stuff, which is the main question you had, I believe that there should be regulations about what AI is trained on. I, unfortunately, do not run OpenAI or any of these other big gigs. I believe there should be guardrails on what AI is allowed to do, what material is given for its training. If it goes to people who have IP that's valuable and is trained on it, then something needs to be sorted. They either need to be paid or not to be used on that." LOL, they absolutely don't understand that if AI didn't steal work, it wouldn't be able to generate anything. That's the whole point of AI.
To me it was always clear they were testing several display solutions. I don't remember them claiming it would be OLED and nothing else. In any case, I don't mind since I don't see how the Switch 2 screen is a downgrade compared to my Switch OLED.
@slider1983 It would have actually been better to make a hack since it requires the original ROM and Nintendo wouldn't care about it. Same problem for the Donkey Kong Land Remake actually. Well, we'll see...
@BlabberBun "You saying "we've been using these things a lot longer and it's harder to live without them" is a pretty poor argument, and is weak analogy at best. Just because something has been normalized doesn't mean you just shrug and go "oh well"." That's absolutely not what I've written, though. I precisely said "and we need to improve A LOT in these areas as well". I'm just saying it's way easier to stop using AI now when we started only a few years ago, and some of us like me didn't even start using it.
@BlabberBun The usual whataboutism. Yes, the Internet also uses too much energy, and clothing uses too much water, and we need to improve A LOT in these areas as well. However, we've been using the Internet and especially clothes for way longer than genAI, so it's way more difficult to live without them. It's crazy some people now claim they can't do anything without AI when they didn't use it at all a few years ago and were fine... They really sound like drug addicts if you ask me (but you won't). Oh, and I'm also "railing against animal agriculture and war" btw, I just don't see the point to do it here, when it has nothing to do with the subject.
I'm starting to be really tired of this "if you don't like AI, ignore it" argument. What they still don't understand is that AI is an ecological disaster, and ignoring all these AI-fueled projects won't make the consequences magically disappear...
Yeah, I'm mildly excited. I bought every expansion card except the Data East/Technos ones, but the last one was already disappointing while some Taito games have been available on consoles but not on the Egret II Mini (Dead Connection or Rastan 3 for instance) yet.
@Brambles I never said emulators are illegal. But you're only supposed to make backup copies... for backup. Otherwise, why don't you sell all your games after making a copy?
@-wc- The idea is that you make a copy before, obviously, 'for archival purposes'. Anyway, the law wasn't designed to allow you to play your games on other systems as well. When you buy a game, you basically buy a license to play that game on a specific system. However it's clear lawmakers didn't know anything about emulation and FPGA. These laws were mostly designed to allow people to copy their personal data, nothing more. So they're obviously full of holes, and until there's a trial going on, there won't be any case-law about it unfortunately.
@Soapy159 I got you the first time, while you apparently didn't read what I said in my last post, in which I replied TO YOU.
Sony would have never asked people to rip their own games for the PS Classic, so the PS Classic (or any official system, if you prefer that word to 'legal' was always at a disadvantage compared to a MISTer. Hence the unfair comparison.
(also, almost nobody will rip their own games when they can download them easily, and also, in the US law at least, you are only allowed to play a copy of a game you owned if the original game doesn't work anymore, so technically, it's still illegal - but nobody cares)
@Soapy159 Of course but that's not our point. An official system would never make you do that. The PS Classic sucked but it had absolutely no means to offer what Superstation One does.
@-wc- Exactly. I also always find a little unfair to compare a legal solution (especially one that offers a limited set of licensed games) to something that is technically legal but, as long as the CD-ROM drive is not available, can only play pirated games.
Yeah, AI is basically the (new) excuse businesses were looking for to get rid of employees. Of course they didn't wait for AI to fire people, but it helps them a lot... And it's no coincidence it fits the current movement of far right governments (that love using AI slop) to cut public services and fire everyone, which leads to numerous disasters.
@KRZY "There is no ethical consumption under capitalism" Well, exactly, capitalism is a dead end. Giving AI a pass just because there's a bigger evil won't fix anything, it actually makes things even worse.
@chucksneed How is it "doing good" for starters? How is a PC port needed? The OG ROM is already preserved online, and there are (many) other ways to play it than a PC port.
Anyway, I totally think it's right to criticize someone doing something good the wrong way, indeed. I could find many examples but I don't think it's allowed to talk politics.
@chucksneed Have you read the article? The port isn't accurate since it wasn't checked by a human. Also, AI is a huge waste of resources. So it really matters (unless you don't care about the world going to *****, obviously).
"This has ruined my perception of the Nintendo brand and will never be purchasing Nintendo products." Something tells me that guy hasn't purchased any Nintendo product for a while, and is looking for an excuse.
I get the idea but I don't think Animal Crossing's neighborly relations are "endlessly deep", though. Sure, the game doesn't focus on exploration and combat like a traditional RPG, but what Miyamoto is describing still doesn't exist imho.
"they're built on the hard work of others, often without permission or remuneration. There's also the issue of developers overrelying on AI for coding and thereby losing essential skills."
For me, the biggest problem is the enormous use of energy.
French Association MO5.COM has been saying it for maybe two decades. The yellowing is a chemical phenomenon at a molecular level and can't be reversed. If you want a bright white system, paint it.
@Alexcastle The US law allows you to make a backup of your game, indeed, but you can only use it if the original doesn't work anymore... On the contrary I think it's useful to remind readers these things are in very grey area in terms of legality. Of course most Time Extension readers are already aware of all that, but the vast majority of people has no clue about IP law.
@wizzgamer Because at the time, the game was only released in Western countries where people didn't care. Which means, actually, the problem would be solved by not releasing the game in Asia.
@The_Nintendo_Pedant Yes, I didn't express myself very well (I'm no native speaker and I was in a hurry). My point is System 3 is a bit dishonest to point the finger at Nintendo while it's a more general issue.
I know dumping on Nintendo is fun, but writing "the company is pointing the finger at Nintendo" then "this issue will also impact the PS4, PS5, and Xbox versions, as the platform holders share similar requirements" is a bit contradictory imho.
This developer created a lot of similar bold prototypes for the 2600, but the problem is he starts a new project almost every month and I'm not sure he finishes any...
I always wanted to play Supreme Warrior. I know it's not a good game, but the FMV sequences were created by real Honk Kong movie studio staff, and it shows imho.
@slider1983 1) He's jealous of the Analogue Pocket that was released before the Chromatic 2) Who cares that the M64 releases before the 3D if it's not as good?
Comments 196
Re: 'I Hope This Wonderful Game Lives On Forever' - Panzer Dragoon Saga Gets PC 'Recomp' from the Dev Behind Yaba Sanshiro
"A true decompilation/recompilation of the game is in the works via yaz0r." Unfortunately he is quite depressed by all the AI-based decompilations and this one won't help...
Re: The King's Return Is a New Medieval Platformer Available in Physical Form for Game Boy Color
"now available to purchase" not really right now because it's already out of stock, but it will be back soon.
Re: Decades After Being Canned, This Excitebike-Like SNES Racer From The Developer Of Plok! Is Finally Getting A Digital Release
I find always weird Time Extension's editors like to write 'later this month' when it's actually THIS WEEK. I mean, isn't it better to have to wait less?
Re: New Old Pixels Signs Deal With Microids To Bring 1989 Arcade Toki To Classic Platforms
Toki has already been unofficially ported to the CPC, though
Re: "If I Didn't Have These Powerful Tools, I Wouldn't Do It at All" - The Oliver Twins Explain Why They're Dizzy About GenAI
"Now, as for scraping IP and all of that kind of stuff, which is the main question you had, I believe that there should be regulations about what AI is trained on. I, unfortunately, do not run OpenAI or any of these other big gigs. I believe there should be guardrails on what AI is allowed to do, what material is given for its training. If it goes to people who have IP that's valuable and is trained on it, then something needs to be sorted. They either need to be paid or not to be used on that."
LOL, they absolutely don't understand that if AI didn't steal work, it wouldn't be able to generate anything. That's the whole point of AI.
Re: "We Completely Shot Ourselves in the Foot" - the Vectrex Mini Just Got a Display Downgrade
To me it was always clear they were testing several display solutions. I don't remember them claiming it would be OLED and nothing else. In any case, I don't mind since I don't see how the Switch 2 screen is a downgrade compared to my Switch OLED.
Re: Game Boy Classic Tennis Comes To Sega Master System In Full Colour (Including Ref Mario)
It's probably made with AI like his other ports, and the channel's name is "Oldschool is beautiful"
Re: Donkey Kong Country's SNES Trilogy Is Getting a Fanmade Sequel Over 10 Years In The Making, With Characters From DK64
@slider1983 It would have actually been better to make a hack since it requires the original ROM and Nintendo wouldn't care about it. Same problem for the Donkey Kong Land Remake actually. Well, we'll see...
Re: Donkey Kong Country's SNES Trilogy Is Getting a Fanmade Sequel Over 10 Years In The Making, With Characters From DK64
@slider1983 That SOME fans have, maybe. Most just play the games and don't try to steal their assets, you know.
Re: Donkey Kong Country's SNES Trilogy Is Getting a Fanmade Sequel Over 10 Years In The Making, With Characters From DK64
@slider1983 If people hate Nintendo, why do they keep paying homage to them?
Re: Something Very Weird Is Happening With PSCD Games' 'Black Jewel Reborn' Mega Drive / Genesis Port
I see they finally got a new YouTube account... The previous one was killed, making all their videos disappear.
Re: Donkey Kong Country's SNES Trilogy Is Getting a Fanmade Sequel Over 10 Years In The Making, With Characters From DK64
Given that the game uses assets from the original games, even if it's free, I doubt Nintendo will let it slide...
Re: "Nobody Is Obligated To Download Or Play It" - Mario Kart 64 And Minish Cap Get Native Dual-Screen 3DS Ports
@BlabberBun "You saying "we've been using these things a lot longer and it's harder to live without them" is a pretty poor argument, and is weak analogy at best. Just because something has been normalized doesn't mean you just shrug and go "oh well"."
That's absolutely not what I've written, though. I precisely said "and we need to improve A LOT in these areas as well". I'm just saying it's way easier to stop using AI now when we started only a few years ago, and some of us like me didn't even start using it.
Re: "Nobody Is Obligated To Download Or Play It" - Mario Kart 64 And Minish Cap Get Native Dual-Screen 3DS Ports
@BlabberBun The usual whataboutism. Yes, the Internet also uses too much energy, and clothing uses too much water, and we need to improve A LOT in these areas as well. However, we've been using the Internet and especially clothes for way longer than genAI, so it's way more difficult to live without them. It's crazy some people now claim they can't do anything without AI when they didn't use it at all a few years ago and were fine... They really sound like drug addicts if you ask me (but you won't).
Oh, and I'm also "railing against animal agriculture and war" btw, I just don't see the point to do it here, when it has nothing to do with the subject.
Re: "Nobody Is Obligated To Download Or Play It" - Mario Kart 64 And Minish Cap Get Native Dual-Screen 3DS Ports
I'm starting to be really tired of this "if you don't like AI, ignore it" argument. What they still don't understand is that AI is an ecological disaster, and ignoring all these AI-fueled projects won't make the consequences magically disappear...
Re: Egret II Mini Livestream Announced For Later This Month, With Its Software Library Set To Hit 100 Titles
Yeah, I'm mildly excited. I bought every expansion card except the Data East/Technos ones, but the last one was already disappointing while some Taito games have been available on consoles but not on the Egret II Mini (Dead Connection or Rastan 3 for instance) yet.
Re: "Extremely Disappointing" - Are AI-Generated FPGA Cores The Future, Or The Death Of Accuracy?
Not only that but these cores are once again ports of software emulators, instead of retro-engineering the original boards. That's quite terrible.
Re: "Spin the Maze, Roll the Ball!" - Taito's Quirky Puzzler 'Cameltry' Is Heading To Switch, PlayStation, & Xbox
You haven't played Cameltry until you've played it with a paddle controller, though.
Re: "I Am Not Making Up This Story" - You Won't Believe What Yuji Naka Wanted To Call Billy Hatcher And The Giant Egg
I wonder if he wasn't trying to make a joke though, and it was literally lost in translation.
Re: Sacré Bleu! Atari Is No Longer A French Company
It's "Sacrebleu". One word, no accent.
Re: You Can Now Legally Rip Your Wii, GameCube And Xbox Discs Using A Blu-Ray Drive
@Brambles I never said emulators are illegal. But you're only supposed to make backup copies... for backup. Otherwise, why don't you sell all your games after making a copy?
Re: You Can Now Legally Rip Your Wii, GameCube And Xbox Discs Using A Blu-Ray Drive
The US law says you can back up your games "for archival purposes", not to play them using emulation, but whatever.
Re: "An Intelligent, Good-Humoured, Down-To-Earth Hippie" - A Tribute To Roy Ozaki, CEO Of 'Pang' Creator Mitchell Corporation
I remember very well the anecdote about yakuzas. I pictured it like a scene from a Takeshi Kitano movie.
Re: Review: SuperStation One - This $210 FPGA PlayStation Puts Sony's PS Classic To Shame
@-wc- The idea is that you make a copy before, obviously, 'for archival purposes'. Anyway, the law wasn't designed to allow you to play your games on other systems as well. When you buy a game, you basically buy a license to play that game on a specific system. However it's clear lawmakers didn't know anything about emulation and FPGA. These laws were mostly designed to allow people to copy their personal data, nothing more. So they're obviously full of holes, and until there's a trial going on, there won't be any case-law about it unfortunately.
Re: Review: SuperStation One - This $210 FPGA PlayStation Puts Sony's PS Classic To Shame
@Soapy159 I got you the first time, while you apparently didn't read what I said in my last post, in which I replied TO YOU.
Sony would have never asked people to rip their own games for the PS Classic, so the PS Classic (or any official system, if you prefer that word to 'legal' was always at a disadvantage compared to a MISTer. Hence the unfair comparison.
(also, almost nobody will rip their own games when they can download them easily, and also, in the US law at least, you are only allowed to play a copy of a game you owned if the original game doesn't work anymore, so technically, it's still illegal - but nobody cares)
Re: Review: SuperStation One - This $210 FPGA PlayStation Puts Sony's PS Classic To Shame
@Soapy159 Of course but that's not our point. An official system would never make you do that. The PS Classic sucked but it had absolutely no means to offer what Superstation One does.
Re: Review: SuperStation One - This $210 FPGA PlayStation Puts Sony's PS Classic To Shame
@-wc- Exactly. I also always find a little unfair to compare a legal solution (especially one that offers a limited set of licensed games) to something that is technically legal but, as long as the CD-ROM drive is not available, can only play pirated games.
Re: "You Cannot Claim Ignorance" - Myst Co-Creator Under Fire For Using GenAI Art In Riven Soundtrack Release
Yeah, AI is basically the (new) excuse businesses were looking for to get rid of employees. Of course they didn't wait for AI to fire people, but it helps them a lot... And it's no coincidence it fits the current movement of far right governments (that love using AI slop) to cut public services and fire everyone, which leads to numerous disasters.
Re: "A Hollow Victory" - '100% AI-Generated' Smash Bros. PC Port Comes Under Fire
@KRZY "There is no ethical consumption under capitalism"
Well, exactly, capitalism is a dead end. Giving AI a pass just because there's a bigger evil won't fix anything, it actually makes things even worse.
Re: "A Hollow Victory" - '100% AI-Generated' Smash Bros. PC Port Comes Under Fire
@chucksneed How is it "doing good" for starters? How is a PC port needed? The OG ROM is already preserved online, and there are (many) other ways to play it than a PC port.
Anyway, I totally think it's right to criticize someone doing something good the wrong way, indeed. I could find many examples but I don't think it's allowed to talk politics.
Re: "A Hollow Victory" - '100% AI-Generated' Smash Bros. PC Port Comes Under Fire
@chucksneed Have you read the article? The port isn't accurate since it wasn't checked by a human. Also, AI is a huge waste of resources. So it really matters (unless you don't care about the world going to *****, obviously).
Re: Feature: It's Tough Out There, So Check Out These Amazing Websites
Rather than Indie Retro News, I would recommend subscribing directly to Saberman's YT channel since most of IRN's news come from it.
Re: "War Is Not A Video Game" - White House Social Media Post Mixing Iran War Footage With Nintendo's 'Wii Sports' Triggers Outcry
"This has ruined my perception of the Nintendo brand and will never be purchasing Nintendo products."
Something tells me that guy hasn't purchased any Nintendo product for a while, and is looking for an excuse.
Re: Shigeru Miyamoto Predicted Animal Crossing's Appeal Over A Decade Before It Launched
I get the idea but I don't think Animal Crossing's neighborly relations are "endlessly deep", though. Sure, the game doesn't focus on exploration and combat like a traditional RPG, but what Miyamoto is describing still doesn't exist imho.
Re: "I'm Just Enjoying Building Software With Those New Tools" - Yaba Sanshiro Dev Credits AI With Saturn Emulator's Renewed Momentum
"they're built on the hard work of others, often without permission or remuneration. There's also the issue of developers overrelying on AI for coding and thereby losing essential skills."
For me, the biggest problem is the enormous use of energy.
Re: A Remake Of The Legendary Sonic Hack 'Sonic Megamix' Is Being Released Next Month
It's also next week if my calculations are correct.
Re: "I Was Strangling Both M2 And Myself" - Sega's Yosuke Okunari Recalls The Painful Relaunch Of The 'Sega Ages' Series
Funnily I would have been very familiar with SDI, under the name Global Defense though.
Re: "They Lied" - New Research Casts Doubt On Analogue 3D Accuracy Claims
Also I wouldn't call that 'research' but whatever.
Re: "Retrobrighting" Might Actually Cause More Harm Than Good To Your Yellowing Consoles
French Association MO5.COM has been saying it for maybe two decades. The yellowing is a chemical phenomenon at a molecular level and can't be reversed. If you want a bright white system, paint it.
Re: Triple Threat Terror Is A Fusion Of Graphic Novel And Game Boy Grappler
btw there's a trailer here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GclbG66LlrA
Re: This Indie Sega Genesis / Mega Drive Title Takes A Leaf Out Of Sonic's Book To Unlock A Bonus Game
"game released in 2023" it was actually released in 2020!
Re: "They Said It Couldn't Be Done" - Indie Dev Brings "Impossible" AI-Generated RPG Concept To Life
Uh... It looks completely different to me.
Re: New Saturn SAROO Flash Cart Firmware Comes With Cool Features And Some Serious Caveats
@Alexcastle The US law allows you to make a backup of your game, indeed, but you can only use it if the original doesn't work anymore... On the contrary I think it's useful to remind readers these things are in very grey area in terms of legality. Of course most Time Extension readers are already aware of all that, but the vast majority of people has no clue about IP law.
Re: "Nintendo Has Made Serious Objections" - Last Ninja Collection Delayed On Consoles
@wizzgamer Because at the time, the game was only released in Western countries where people didn't care. Which means, actually, the problem would be solved by not releasing the game in Asia.
Re: "Nintendo Has Made Serious Objections" - Last Ninja Collection Delayed On Consoles
@KociolekDoSyta No:
"this issue will also impact the PS4, PS5, and Xbox versions, as the platform holders share similar requirements"
Re: "Nintendo Has Made Serious Objections" - Last Ninja Collection Delayed On Consoles
@The_Nintendo_Pedant Yes, I didn't express myself very well (I'm no native speaker and I was in a hurry). My point is System 3 is a bit dishonest to point the finger at Nintendo while it's a more general issue.
Re: "Nintendo Has Made Serious Objections" - Last Ninja Collection Delayed On Consoles
I know dumping on Nintendo is fun, but writing "the company is pointing the finger at Nintendo" then "this issue will also impact the PS4, PS5, and Xbox versions, as the platform holders share similar requirements" is a bit contradictory imho.
Re: Golden Axe Is Being Unofficially Ported To The Atari 2600
This developer created a lot of similar bold prototypes for the 2600, but the problem is he starts a new project almost every month and I'm not sure he finishes any...
Re: Limited Run Games CEO Obtains Rights To Several FMV Games By Night Trap Dev Digital Pictures
I always wanted to play Supreme Warrior. I know it's not a good game, but the FMV sequences were created by real Honk Kong movie studio staff, and it shows imho.
Re: ModRetro's FPGA N64 Uses FPGAzumSpass's MiSTer N64 Core
@slider1983
1) He's jealous of the Analogue Pocket that was released before the Chromatic
2) Who cares that the M64 releases before the 3D if it's not as good?