Comments 201

Re: "Bravo, SNK! What A Greedy Company!" - King Of Fighters XIII Global Match's Steam Launch Has Upset Fans

axelhander

I'm torn because while I do think these companies should provide free rollback when they can AND SNK has been one of them before, I also get that doing so ain't cheap.

BUT some of my sympathy evaporates when I remember how so many people 15 years ago begged and pleaded with Capcom, SNK, and ArcSys to PLEASE use rollback netcode like SF2 HD Remix did so well, and all three were like "lol but what if we don't."

Re: Talking Point: Is There A Home Port You Prefer To The Arcade Original?

axelhander

Loads. Just a few:

  • Every NES Double Dragon looks worse but plays way, way, way better than its arcade counterpart.
  • SNES Turtles in Time is missing 4-player co-op (2 max) and some animations, but has additional stages and bosses, and changes that make it better than the arcade version.
  • NES Castlevania is way better than the arcade Haunted Castle.
  • PSX Tekken 3 outdoes the arcade original (despite less RAM).

Re: Saturn Was "More Powerful Than PlayStation" Claims Argonaut Founder

axelhander

It's a lot like the SNES vs. Genesis vs. TG16/PCE debates: it all depends on what you're pushing and how good the devs are. The Genesis had the most powerful CPU of the three, but the SNES CPU was more efficient and the console had loads of AV bells and whistles, while the TG16 had its own advantages with color palettes and the like.

I bet you if SotN was made for the Saturn first, it would have been spectacular.

Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement

axelhander

@Freyhon Your communication is fine. I understand what you're trying to say.

"AI art simply CTRL+C information from another electronic source then applies focused randomization based on prompts that it only understands as predictive modifiers." <-- Even if this were true, and it isn't, it still wouldn't change anything I'm saying; building upon what has come before to create something new. It is "stolen" in the exact same way a news site's opinion piece is "stolen."

You're hung up on this carbon copy point and I'm not sure why. There isn't code from SMB in Shovel Knight, but even if there was, who cares; the end result remains an original creation. There's a screenshot of the title screen of the NES game Totally Rad in early builds of World of Warcraft, probably used in some sort of prototyping for a UI or something; again, who cares, the end result isn't some carbon copy of Totally Rad.

We start calling usage of these things "theft" then we have to take them to their logical extreme, because I promise you, rich multi-national corporations ABSOLUTELY WILL. And that extreme leads to:

  • Style as trade dress being subject to copyrighting and trademarking. Which means that Disney and Microsoft and Sony and other big organizations will scour their archives, their sat-on IPs, for anything with a distinct style they can claim ownership to. This gives them the legal OK to sue any work, no matter how small, that even remotely looks like it's "infringing." This point could happen very soon, as there are artists fighting for style as trade dress in the misguided hope it will "defeat AI."
  • Copyrighting tropes. Nintendo patenting Pokemon capture mechanics and d-pad designs? That's just the beginning; imagine Disney copyrighting the "coming of age" trope based off of all the properties they owned that use it to some degree.
  • Same thing but with memes. Want to make your own variant of that "enslaved moisture" meme? Get ready for a takedown notice.

These are what AI fearmongering will lead to, what the basic refusal to accept that AI is just another way human beings create new things out of already existing material will result in.

Beyond that, the point stands: AI is just doing via Python or C++ or whatever what the biological human brain does already. But the machine cannot generate value on its own, which is why the fearmongering over it is unjustified. Only a human can take that raw output, from AI or from their own observation of reality, and make it something valuable.