@-wc- The implication is that artists are a charity. They are not. What I said still applies: AI is a tool, and making a title card or store graphic using AI is an affront to no one who isn't looking to be outraged.
AI is amazing but it isn't creative. Like I mentioned in my original example, there'd be a world of difference if it was the sole source of, say, cutscenes. And even then, the issue wouldn't be AI, it would be that said cutscenes, devoid of human editing or direction, would feel hollow and lifeless.
@RupeeClock It's a stupid sentiment. AI is a tool. There's a world of difference between selling AI work as your own to a client who was promised something that wasn't AI generated, and using AI tools to create cover art for a thing you're selling yourself.
An artist was not shortchanged here. It isn't shortchanging someone who was never involved in your project and that you were never planning TO involve in the first place. The fearmongering over this cover art remains dumb.
Anyone who paid for this needs to turn into a Karen, demand their money back, and get their credit card companies to reverse the charge. ***** scammers.
I could see the outrage if there was like a suite of artwork that the game featured, like if it was an RPG with Phantasy Star IV style cutscenes where every one of them was AI generated. And even then, the issue would be that said scenes would look robotic and lifeless for something that's supposed to convey emotion and themes and the like.
Here, it's for the cover art, and the final result does the job well enough.
@DestructoDisk "When will the controller gods bless us with a bluetooth controller that has 6 primary face button as well as 4 shoulder buttons and two analog sticks?"
@RootsGenoa No, it wasn't a friendly suggestion; it was a smug, snide dismissal clearly aligned with the corporate views of Nintendo, someone you're clearly a blind fan of. Hence, their corporate foot in your awaiting mouth.
There will come a day when we as a species will move past regressive and repressive copyright laws and plagiarism fear-mongering. On that day, cool projects like this will pop up everywhere and Nintendo will thankfully get no say.
Until then, download this ASAP before Nintendo's lawyers descend and their drooling fanbase cheers.
Been a fan of Castlevania since the 80s. The original Netflix series was incredible; fantastic animation, dialogue, characterizations, just a joy all around. And Nocturne is more of that. Good stuff.
Comments 137
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
@SlangWon Agreed 100%.
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
@-wc- Art is valuable. Necessary. Soul-warming.
None of what I said invalidates any of that, and attempting to twist my position into that is malicious at best.
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
@PinballBuzzbro Already addressed and dismissed. Scroll up.
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
@gojiguy Big tech has been scraping your data for decades, and Google has not compensated you for one red cent.
The issue is not AI, it's class society where corporations get to use your data for free and sell it back to you at a premium.
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
@jojobar Your money is your own and you may opt to purchase something, or refrain, for any reason you see fit.
Everything I said still stands.
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
@-wc- The implication is that artists are a charity. They are not. What I said still applies: AI is a tool, and making a title card or store graphic using AI is an affront to no one who isn't looking to be outraged.
AI is amazing but it isn't creative. Like I mentioned in my original example, there'd be a world of difference if it was the sole source of, say, cutscenes. And even then, the issue wouldn't be AI, it would be that said cutscenes, devoid of human editing or direction, would feel hollow and lifeless.
That isn't a concern for a freaking title card.
This is fearmongering over nothing.
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
@Steel76 Now this, I can appreciate.
Voxels are rad.
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
@RupeeClock It's a stupid sentiment. AI is a tool. There's a world of difference between selling AI work as your own to a client who was promised something that wasn't AI generated, and using AI tools to create cover art for a thing you're selling yourself.
An artist was not shortchanged here. It isn't shortchanging someone who was never involved in your project and that you were never planning TO involve in the first place. The fearmongering over this cover art remains dumb.
Re: If Nothing Else, SuperSega's Latest "Review" Should Convince You To Keep Your Wallet Shut
Anyone who paid for this needs to turn into a Karen, demand their money back, and get their credit card companies to reverse the charge. ***** scammers.
Re: Accusations Of AI Art Deflate Archer Maclean's DropZone 40th Anniversary Announcement
Who cares. AI fearmongering is stupid.
I could see the outrage if there was like a suite of artwork that the game featured, like if it was an RPG with Phantasy Star IV style cutscenes where every one of them was AI generated. And even then, the issue would be that said scenes would look robotic and lifeless for something that's supposed to convey emotion and themes and the like.
Here, it's for the cover art, and the final result does the job well enough.
Who. Cares.
Re: We're Getting A New Magic Knight Game Next Year To Mark The Character's 40th Anniversary
@jesse_dylan I too thought this was about Rayearth, and when I didn't see Hikaru I was all confused.
Re: Talking Point: With Sonic's Movie Series Set To Cross A Billion Dollars At The Box Office, It's A Shame His Creator Doesn't Get Credit
@raider266 In your haste to be a wokescold you didn't even read the article.
Protip: don't be a wokescold. Terrible thing to aspire to.
Re: Talking Point: With Sonic's Movie Series Set To Cross A Billion Dollars At The Box Office, It's A Shame His Creator Doesn't Get Credit
He should get credited. The movies are fantastic and Ohshima deserves praise.
Re: Star Fox 64 Is Getting A Fanmade PC Port With High Framerate Support
a) Though in early access, folks who want a spiritual successor to classic Starfox games should look at Ex-Zodiac. It's rad. https://store.steampowered.com/app/1249480/ExZodiac/
2) I hope this SF64 PC port gets released before Nintendo takes it down and the drooling Nintendo kiddies cheer.
Re: Random: Here's The Story Of Why Capcom's SNES Aladdin Game Didn't Feature A Sword
Yeah, SNES Aladdin is the waaaaaaaaaaaaay better game.
Re: Trials Of Mana Is Being Adapted Into A Stage Play To Celebrate Its 30th Anniversary
But why though
Re: Sega Wanted Phantasy Star IV To Flop In The West, Hence The Sky-High $100 Price
@Daniel36 Love and respect. <3 And to be fair I do love Chrono Trigger too. Chrono Cross, however...
Re: Sega Wanted Phantasy Star IV To Flop In The West, Hence The Sky-High $100 Price
Interesting.
Phantasy Star IV remains one of the best 16-bit JRPGs ever. It's a better game than Chrono Trigger; fight me.
Re: SuperSega Explains Why It Produces Such "Crappy" Videos, Says It's Afraid Analogue Will Steal Its Ideas
@PinballBuzzbro You keep the pill lady away from me
Re: SuperSega Explains Why It Produces Such "Crappy" Videos, Says It's Afraid Analogue Will Steal Its Ideas
Removed
Re: Pre-Orders For FPGA N64 'Analogue 3D' Open Next Week, Will Cost $250
@DestructoDisk "When will the controller gods bless us with a bluetooth controller that has 6 primary face button as well as 4 shoulder buttons and two analog sticks?"
RIGHT? I wish 6 face buttons became the norm.
Re: Someone Has Finally Found A Use For The NES Expansion Port
@PopetheRev28 omg could you imagine
Re: Someone Has Finally Found A Use For The NES Expansion Port
@-wc- As a kid I'd often flip the thing over and wonder what could be.
Re: Nintendo Is Now Going After YouTube Accounts Which Show Its Games Being Emulated
@RootsGenoa No, it wasn't a friendly suggestion; it was a smug, snide dismissal clearly aligned with the corporate views of Nintendo, someone you're clearly a blind fan of. Hence, their corporate foot in your awaiting mouth.
Re: Nintendo Is Now Going After YouTube Accounts Which Show Its Games Being Emulated
@RootsGenoa Evidently.
Re: Nintendo Is Now Going After YouTube Accounts Which Show Its Games Being Emulated
@RootsGenoa Having Nintendo's entire boot in your mouth ain't a good look.
Re: Nintendo Is Now Going After YouTube Accounts Which Show Its Games Being Emulated
You don't hate Nintendo enough.
Re: This Adorable New Super Mario Fan Game Looks Absolutely Incredible
Looks cute.
I hate that Nintendo is going to take it down, and that Nintendo glazers are going to cheer that move.
Re: This Adorable New Super Mario Fan Game Looks Absolutely Incredible
@Bonggon5 k
Re: Talking Point: Does Video Game History Have A "Nintendo Problem"?
Nintendo's contribution to video game history cannot be understated AND Nintendo fans do, in fact, live in a bubble.
Re: 'Mario Builder 64' Is Super Mario Maker For Mario 64
There will come a day when we as a species will move past regressive and repressive copyright laws and plagiarism fear-mongering. On that day, cool projects like this will pop up everywhere and Nintendo will thankfully get no say.
Until then, download this ASAP before Nintendo's lawyers descend and their drooling fanbase cheers.
Re: Poll: What Is Rare's Best Game?
DKC2 wins hands down. DKC3 is a close second, and DKC1 a close third.
Re: The Making Of: Mario Is Missing, The Plumber's Oddest Adventure
The Mario edutainment games were not for me but they were hardly bad.
Re: Random: This Frasier Beat 'Em Up Mock-Up Needs To Be A Real Game
Niles WOULD have a higher AGI stat than Fraser. And lower STR.
Re: Sega Is "Evaluating" A New Virtua Fighter
No rollback no buy. Rollback netcode is the bare minimum, and something Sega skimped on in the VF5 re-release.
Re: New NHL '94 Genesis ROM Hack Updates The Game For The 2023-2024 Season
NHL '94 is the only hockey game I've ever liked.
Re: Review: Castlevania: Nocturne - Richter And Company Take Netflix's Gory Series To New Heights
Been a fan of Castlevania since the 80s. The original Netflix series was incredible; fantastic animation, dialogue, characterizations, just a joy all around. And Nocturne is more of that. Good stuff.