Image: Plug In Digital

The publisher Red Art Games has recently come under fire from some customers and former business partners over delayed deliveries and late & missing payments.

The freelance journalist Marion Bargiacchi broke the story last week on the French gaming newsletter Origami (with the story being forwarded to Time Extension via our news tips). In that newsletter, she not only spoke to Red Art customers who had been left waiting extended periods of time for shipping, but also to those who had collaborated with Red Art Games to get their games released. This includes the developer Cyrille Bonard, whose 2022 indie game Ruggnar was meant to get a physical Nintendo Switch edition via Red Art Games.

"Developers alerted me to the situation regarding Red Art Games," Bargiacchi told Time Extension. "Through several sources, I was quickly able to get in touch with numerous dissatisfied studios that had either not been paid or had been paid very late. It was not difficult to obtain accounts of what happened; however, many chose to remain anonymous or to speak off the record."

As Bargiacchi notes in the newsletter, in the case of Ruggnar, the physical version of the game was originally supposed to ship in January 2024, but remains unreleased to this day after various delays (the website now states 2027). As a result, Bonard shared his disappointment publicly with the journalist, stating that he had been left to deal with the fallout from disappointed and angry customers, despite having absolutely nothing to do with fulfilment.

Responding to this, Red Art Games' founder Michael Binkowski provided various explanations to Bargiacchi for these delays, from "cartridge supplies for the Switch" to "poor scheduling" and the failure of some of its previous projects having an impact on the company's finances and structuring:

"Red Art Games has always been and remains a small, independent company. Unfortunately, some of our 2024 and 2025 projects did not achieve the expected success and have significantly impacted the company's finances. While the situation has been difficult for Red Art Games, we know that it has also been, and continues to be, difficult for many other companies, including several of our partners. I cannot go into details for reasons of confidentiality, but it is not our intention to disregard the agreements we have signed."

Fortunately, in the case of Bonard, he was able to be paid the €10,000 minimum guaranteed payment stipulated in his contract with Red Art Games, but others haven't been as lucky, with another developer, Flying Oak Studios' CEO Thomas Altenburger, telling Bargiacchi that his studio is owed between €5,000 and €10,000 from Red Art Games, as part of their contract to release ScourgeBringer physically.

Much like Ruggnar, ScourgeBringer was also published digitally by Plug In Digital, which was the company that originally connected Altenburger with Red Art Games. Plug In Digital, however, has also had its own issues with Red Art Games, with the digital publisher's CEO, Francis Ingrand, telling Bargiacchi it has yet to see any sales statements regarding ScourgeBringer or any corresponding payments related to the game (despite it being listed as sold out on the Red Art Games' website). As a result, it ceased its collaboration with the company two to three years ago.

I reached out to Plug In Digital to see what this meant. After all, Plug In Digital's games are listed for pre-order on the website. I was curious if this only referred to future titles, but Plug In Digital provided me with the following statement, suggesting it also applied to titles Red Art Games is still accepting orders for:

"Even though some games might still show up for preorders on their website, we confirm the contracts have expired, and we haven't been in contact with them for a few years now."

Of course, it isn't just developers and publishers who have voiced concerns about Red Art Games, but customers who have ordered from the company. As Bargiacchi notes in the newsletter, Red Art Games provided an update on X and Bluesky to its customers in September, apologising for several delays to its products, and gave a revised timetable for a number of its titles that are still awaiting shipping.

Last Friday, in the hopes of finding out more, I reached out to Red Art Games with the following questions:

"I'm curious, what are the reasons for these delays? The article mentions Nintendo Switch cartridge shortages, poor scheduling, and the impact of a market contraction on Red Art Games. Is that accurate? Are these problems that the company has now successfully overcome, or still having an ongoing impact on the company? Is there a reason some games (Broken Sword: Reforged) are less impacted than others?

More alarmingly, I also saw that the French article includes some comments from Thomas Altenburger (of Flying Oak Studios) and Francis Ingrand (of Plug In Digital) about a lack of transparency regarding sales and non-payments with regard to Scourgebringer. Is Red Art Games currently trying to rectify this situation?"

Additionally, I also asked Red Art Games whether Plug In Digital's comments about expired contracts were accurate, and whether this meant the company could no longer release games like Ruggnar, as previously planned.

In a lengthy statement, Red Art Games' Michael Binkowski replied:

"Regarding the delayed releases of some of our physical games, as gamers and collectors ourselves, we understand how frustrating such delays can be, and we apologize for keeping our customers waiting. Red Art Games is an independent company with a small team, and we take great pride in releasing high-quality physical games. However, the production process for some of our larger titles took considerably longer and required significantly more resources than anticipated. Unfortunately, this caused us to fall behind schedule on certain releases.

Over the last few months, we have completely reworked our production methodology, putting us in a much better position going forward. We plan to make an announcement regarding our 2027 release schedule before the end of the year. We are extremely grateful for everyone’s patience and would once again like to apologize for these delays.

Regarding Kickstarter campaigns, it is important to reiterate that we are not responsible for running the campaigns themselves. Red Art Games acts solely as the supplier of the products ordered by the project owners. Kickstarter projects often take considerably longer to complete than initially anticipated, and as a backer of multiple campaigns myself, I know full well how frustrating it can be to wait years to receive your rewards.

That being said, we are dependent on the approvals and timelines of the project owners, who are often primarily focused on developing their games and are themselves running behind schedule. With Ratatan, for example, we are in constant communication with the team behind the project, and things are progressing. Backers will receive their rewards, and we once again appreciate their patience and understanding. As demonstrated by the Broken Sword Reforged rewards, we place the utmost importance on the quality of the products we create.

Regarding late sales reports, this is indeed something that has happened in the past in a small number of cases. To prevent this from happening again, we brought on a new team member last year whose primary responsibility is to ensure that sales reports are prepared and submitted in a timely manner. We are aware that a few reports are still outstanding, and we intend to bring everything up to date as soon as possible. I want to emphasize that it has never been our intention to fail to honor the terms of our agreements with our partners.

As for Ruggnar, we will be contacting PID to address the situation. We always stop selling games once the corresponding publishing agreement has expired. If an oversight has occurred on our end, we will make sure it is promptly addressed.

We greatly appreciate everyone’s patience, understanding and support as we navigate the challenges of an ever-changing video game industry. Over the seven years since its founding, Red Art Games has, like any company, experienced its fair share of ups and downs. Around two years ago, we encountered some difficulties that caused us to fall behind on a number of projects. However, we have worked hard to get things back on track, and we look forward to sharing our plans for 2027 with players soon.”

We recommend checking out Bargiacchi's full report here. You can support Bargiacchi's investigative and video interviews via Patreon.

[source origami.ng]