
Reviews are now out for Amazon Prime's much-hyped John Madden biopic, directed by David O. Russell and starring Nicolas Cage as the famous NFL coach, commentator and (via EA's million-selling franchise) video game icon.
While the movie covers Madden's entire career, it also focuses on his partnership with Electronic Arts founder Trip Hawkins (played by SNL star John Mulaney), one of the first people in the game industry to see the benefit of collaborating with sporting personalities on official video games.
Has Russell's movie hit the spot? Well, not really, according to critics. Here's what they've been saying.
The AV Club
"John Madden was a man of titanic accomplishments: a Super Bowl-winning coach; a beloved, jolly sportscaster; a video game mogul. A Hall Of Famer, Oakland Raiders royalty, and the biggest personality in any room. Filmmaker David O. Russell tries to capture all of that in Madden, his direct-to-Prime-Video biodramedy, but it’s a disaster. It’s not like Russell fumbles on the goal line—he muffs the opening kickoff, blows his ACL, and gets carted off the field."
The Daily Beast
"Madden imparts a wealth of baseline information about Madden and absolutely zero about his heart and mind. Perhaps that’s because, as Russell contends, he was just a lovably oafish football fanatic who couldn’t stop devising creative new plays and never lost his adoration for the game. That’s not much to hang a movie on, however, and the director can’t even do that properly, sabotaging everything by staging his material with amateur-hour gracelessness."
Screen Daily
"Madden’s most unrewarding passages come near the end, when Russell recounts how the videogame John Madden Football — later known as Madden NFL — was created, despite Madden’s utter disinterest in videogames. Playing the ambitious, nerdy Hawkins, stand-up comedian Mulaney struggles to bring the thinly-drawn character to life. And the detailing of the game’s gradual technological improvements (better graphics, more realistic game play) possess – much like the film itself – little pizzazz."
Slant Magazine
"Russell’s penchant for broad comedy eventually crowds out his humanistic side. So cartoonish and over-the-top are Cage’s and Bale’s performances (not to mention their wigs) that you’re always fully, at times painfully, aware that you’re watching Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale rather than John Madden and Al Davis. Kathryn Hahn is an oasis of restraint by comparison, and she also gets to play more than one note. Which is more than can be said for Sienna Miller as Davis’s wife, Carol, a role so thankless that she might as well not be there at all."
The Wrap
"Everyone seems to like John Madden. The man took the Oakland Raiders to their first Super Bowl win in the 1970s and he’s still considered one of the greatest football coaches in history. After he retired, Madden’s televised color commentary brought joy to millions of sports fans. He even became a major player in the video game world, bringing strategy and realism to the sports genre with EA’s “Madden NFL” series. To quote the bards, Salt ‘n’ Pepa (and En Vogue): “What a man, what a man, what a man, what a mighty good man.”
On one hand it makes sense to produce a film about John Madden’s life, since he’s still famous and beloved five years after his passing. On the other hand it makes no sense at all, because if “Madden” is to be believed, there’s no story to tell. He was a genius and everyone respected him. He was a workaholic yet his wife, Virginia (Kathryn Hahn), always forgave him. He was best friends with Al Davis (Christian Bale), the owner of the Raiders, and although they had an argument — once — they remained best friends. The film is undeniably pleasant, but neither interesting nor insightful."